USDOL/OALJ Law Library: SCA Appeals Decisions

Service Contract Act Appeals Decisions: 1987 - Current

---

This library of Service Contract Appeals decisions was provided by the Board of Service Contracts Appeals. It consists primarily of Secretary of Labor and Board of Service Contract Appeals decisions, although some administrative law judge decisions are included. For a library of recent ALJ decisions, see the "Service Contract Act - ALJ Decisions" library.

Note: The case numbers assigned by the BSCA do not correspond to the OALJ case numbers, although the format is similar.

Note: Effective April 17, 1996, the BSCA was eliminated, and jurisdiction passed to the Administrative Review Board. See the ARB Wage Appeals Decision caselist .

---

• 0855-SCA AMCOR, INC. & E.E. LECHNER
  
• 0876-SCA Menlo Service Corp. & Daniel Sloan
  
• 0945-SCA Kleen-Rite Corporation
  
• 0961-SCA AFGHAN CARPET CLEANERS, INC.
  
• 0983-SCA National Electro- Coatings, Inc.
  
• 1018-SCA Chas. Judd d/b/a QC Services
  
• 1046-SCA Lawrence J. Cook d/b/a Cook Bldg. Maint.
  
• 1046-SCA Lawrence J. Cook d/b/a Cook Bldg. Maint.
  
• 1121-SCA Chas. W. Gilford d/b/a Integrity Service
  
• 1156-SCA Andrew Serafin Trucking Co.
  
• 1168-SCA Metropolitan Van & Storage, Inc.
  
• 1175-SCA Electro-Spray, Inc.
  
• 1176-SCA CLARKIE'S, INC. AND MILTON CLARK
  
• 1181-SCA ATEC, INC. COMMERCIAL OVERHAUL, ET AL.
  
• 1181-SCA ATEC, INC., ET AL.
  
• 1181-SCA ATEC, Inc., Commercial overhaul, et al.
  
• 1182-SCA E.V. ALLEN AND ASSOCIATES, INC.
  
• 1183-SCA Young Patrol Service, Inc.
  
• 1193-SCA Hertzler Enterprises d/b/a Sandia Die
  
• 1208-SCA Ambassador Inns of America, Inc.
  
• 1229-SCA JAMES B. HEWETTE D/B/A HEWETTE MAIL
  
• 1233-SCA NISSI CORPORATION AND ANDREW GODBOTT
  
• 1235-SCA CUSTODIAL GUIDANCE SYSTEMS, INC., ET AL.
  
• 1237-SCA Goodall's Charter Bus Service
  
• 1253-SCA John A. Musilli d/b/a Commercial Fleet
  
• 1258-SCA K & P JANITORIAL SERVICE, INC.
  
• 1258-SCA K&P Janitorial Service, Inc.
  
• 1317-SCA FRED VAN ELK, ET AL.
  
• 1341-SCA AIRLINE INSTRUMENTS, INC. & DALE IRELAND
  
• 1387-SCA ROB SWEAT AND ASSOCIATES, ET AL.
  
• 80-SCA-1291 JOHN R. MOTT, INC.
  
• 81-SCA-1308 PAT'S JANITORIAL SERVICE, INC., ET AL
  
• 81-SCA-1325 Urban Laboratories, Inc. & G. Burke
  
• 81-SCA-1355 PRYOR'S COURT, INC., ET AL.
  
• 81-SCA-1390 SIDNEY W. JOHNSON DBA SOUTHWESTERN FILM
  
• 81-SCA-1413r AAA DESK PAINTERS, INC., ET AL.
  
• 81-SCA-1413 AAA DESK PAINTERS, INC., ET AL.
  
• 81-SCA-1431 Aubrey 0. Prince d/b/a Contract Cleaning
  
• 81-SCA-1436 GENERAL SYSTEMS INT'L DBA SIX RIVERS AIR
  
• 82-SCA-7 VIGILANTES, INC. & ANGEL L. PEDROSA

  See also Vigilantes, Inc. v. USDOL, 968 F.2d 1412 (1st Cir. 1992)

• 82-SCA-9 Phil Maestas
  
• 82-SCA-29 CLARENCE R. PAUL & G.D. TRANSPORTATION
  
• 82-SCA-32n COUNTS, TREADWAY & JOE'S GARAGE
  
• 82-SCA-32 COUNTS, TREADWAY & JOE'S GARAGE
  
• 82-SCA-37 LOVELL WADDLE, JR.
  
• 82-SCA-44e VERTICARE, A CORP. (ERRATA)
  
• 82-SCA-44 VERTICARE, A CORP. & JAMES T. CHEATHAM
  
• 82-SCA-45 WILLIAM A. CIMPI D/B/A CIMPI TRANSPORT.
  
• 82-SCA-48 OHIO BUILDING SERVICE MAINTENANCE
  
• 82-SCA-66 Kaiser Heating & Air Conditioning Co.
  
• 82-SCA-78 LEROY F. SURFACE
  
• 82-SCA-81 ACTION SYSTEMS, INC. & ACTION BLDG. SYS.
  
• 82-SCA-106 HABITECH, INC., ET AL.
  
• 82-SCA-127r MELTON SALES & SERVICES, INC., ET AL.
  
• 82-SCA-136b JOY R. MANNING DBA MANNING MAIL SERVICE
  
• 82-SCA-136 JOY R. MANNING D/B/A MANNING MAIL SERV.
  
• 82-SCA-137 J. Marshall Brown & Owl Const. Co., Inc.
  
• 82-SCA-139 Hamilton Transfer- Storage Feed, Inc.
  
• 82-SCA-144r ED BIRD AND ED BIRD TRUCKING, INC.
  
• 82-SCA-144 ED BIRD AND ED BIRD TRUCKING, INC.
  
• 82-SCA-147 Lawrence W. Vest
  
• 83-SCA-5 ONEIDA BUILDING SERVICES, INC.
  
• 83-SCA-16r SOUTHEASTERN MAIL TRANSPORT, INC. ETAL.
  
• 83-SCA-23 Paul and Shirley Strand
  
• 83-SCA-49 Wm. A. Cimpi d/b/a Cimpi Trans.
  
• 83-SCA-63 MIRES AND SCARLETT, ET AL.
  
• 83-SCA-77 ASSOCIATED CLEANING CONSULTANTS, ET AL.
  
• 83-SCA-90r CYCLE BUILDING MAINTENANCE, INC.
  
• 83-SCA-90 CYCLE BUILDING MAINTENANCE, INC.
  
• 83-SCA-98 Advance Maint. Co., Walter Hawzen
  
• 83-SCA-101 Allan Motley d/b/a Motley Shampooing
  
• 83-SCA-111 JOS. C. KIRCHDORFER DBA SKIP KIRCHDORFER
  
• 84-SCA-11 COMPLETE BUILDING MAINTENANCE, ET AL
  
• 84-SCA-2 Rainey Fabricating, Inc.
  
• 84-SCA-32r WILLIAM POWELL, JR. & BLDG. MAINT. SPEC.
  
• 84-SCA-32 WILLIAM POWELL, JR. & BLDG. MAINT. SPEC.
  
• 84-SCA-32s WILLIAM POWELL, JR. & BLDG. MAINT. SPEC.
  
• 84-SCA-48 JED-SPG, Inc. & Jones E. Davis
  
• 84-SCA-50 CROWN LAUNDRY AND DRY CLEANERS
  
• 84-SCA-61 HOWARD PUBLICATIONS D/B/A CASPER STAR
  
• 84-SCA-95r NATIONWIDE BLDG. & OHIO BLDG. SERVICE
  
• 84-SCA-95 NATIONWIDE BLDG. MAINT. & OHIO BLDG. SER
  • Nationwide Bldg. Maintenance, Inc. v. Reich , 14 F.3d 1102 (6th Cir. 1994)(delay in establishing Board of Service Contract Appeals does not divest interim authority of Secretary)

• 84-SCA-109 JAMES R. ERBES DBA SUNNYBROOK CONTRACTOR
  
• 84-SCA-110 C.R. Jones d/b/a C.R. Jones Logging Co.
  
• 85-SCA-1 SCOPE Exchange Contracts
  
• 85-SCA-4 RACOA INTERNATIONAL, INC.
  
• 85-SCA-8 HERBERT GEVING D/B/A GEVING SANITATION
  
• 85-SCA-9 GEORGE KIM D/B/A KOREAN MAINTENANCE
  
• 85-SCA-10 APPLING, JANITORIAL SERVICE, ET AL.
  
• 85-SCA-19 GAYLORD AND ASSOCIATES CORP.
  
• 85-SCA-22 HANDYMAN BUILDING MAINTENANCE COMPANY, INC.
  
• 85-SCA-22e HANDYMAN BUILDING MAINTENANCE CO., INC.
  
• 85-SCA-25 WHITE WAY TRUCKING, INC. & CHERYL VAZZA
  
• 85-SCA-53r COLORADO SECURITY AGENCY, INC.
  
• 85-SCA-53 COLORADO SECURITY AGENCY, INC.
  
• 85-SCA-69 ROBERT BALSAMA D/B/A BELLA ENTERPRISES
  
• 85-SCA-98 A TO Z MAINTENANCE & SAMUEL WILLIAMS
  
• 85-SCA-98s A TO Z MAINTENANCE & SAMUEL WILLIAMS
  
• 86-SCA-9 TOM JERNIGAN DBA JERNIGAN'S BACKHOE
  
• 86-SCA-30r LE-GALS, INC. (RECON)
  
• 86-SCA-30 LE-GALS, INC.
  
• 86-SCA-40 DEANNA E. DONACA
  
• 86-SCA-45 JAMES W. MORRIS, INC.
  
• 86-SCA-46 RELIABLE JANITORIAL SERVICE, INC.
  
• 86-SCA-63 WINSTON ORCHARDS, INC.
  
• 86-SCA-65 M.E.S. SERVICES, INC. & GERALD BATCHELOR
  
• 86-SCA-71 NOVATO DISPOSAL SERV. & JAMES RATTO
  
• 86-SCA-85 MARY BEIER D/B/A BLDG. MAINT. SPECIALIST
  
• 87-SCA-9 STANCIL G. JONES
  
• 87-SCA-10 HENRY BURTON D/B/A BURTON MAIL MESSENGER
  
• 87-SCA-11 DEL TRANSPORT, INC., ET AL.
  
• 87-SCA-16 KEVIN BITHER DBA BITHER TRUCKING
  
• 87-SCA-23 COMMAND TECH CORP. & RICHARD BROWN
  
• 87-SCA-32r CINDY MONAHAN, ADMINISTRATOR (RUT'S)
  
• 87-SCA-32 CHAS. RANDALL DBA RUT'S MOVING & DELIV.
  
• 87-SCA-43 MAINTENANCE ENGINEERS AND BRADLEY HERMAN
  
• 87-SCA-83 SAM AYRES
  
• 87-SCA-131 JOHN BLOOD
  
• 88-SCA-32 ANDRES SHARIPOFF D/B/A BSR COMPANY
  
• 88-SCA-42 B.K.E. ASSOCIATES, INC. & EDWARD KING
  
• 88-SCA-68 RICHARD MC GLUMPHY
  
• 88-SCA-98 WHITE GLOVE CLEANING SERVICE
  
• 90-SCA-1 NEEB-KEARNEY AND COMPANY, INC., and ADMINISTRATOR, WAGE AND HOUR DIVISION, EMPLOYMENT STANDARDS ADMINISTRATION, UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
  
• 91-SCA-1 AQUASIS SERVICES, INC.
  
• 91-SCA-5 HARBERT INTERNATIONAL, INC., CONTRACT AT FORT LEONARD WOOD, MISSOURI AND ADMINISTRATOR, WAGE AND HOUR DIVISION, EMPLOYMENT STANDARDS ADMINISTRATION, UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
  
• 92-SCA-1 SEIU re NATIONWIDE FRINGE BENEFITS
  
• 92-SCA-2 MC DONALD'S CORPORATION
  
• 92-SCA-3 FLORIDA TRANSPORTATION SERVICE, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-4 NATIONWIDE BUILDING MAINTENANCE,INC.
  
• 92-SCA-5 TRI-WAY SECURITY AND ESCORT SERVICES
  
• 92-SCA-6 CYNTHIA E. AIKEN & CHARLES D. EADDY
  
• 92-SCA-7 ELAINE'S CLEANING SERVICE
  • See also Elaine's Cleaning Serv. v. United States Dept. of Labor , No. 95-4273 (6th Cir. Feb. 13, 1997)

• 92-SCA-8 CRIMSON ENTERPRISES, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-8m CRIMSON ENTERPRISES, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-8r CRIMSON ENTERPRISES, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-9 KLEEN-RITE CORPORATION & H. GREENSPAN
  
• 92-SCA-9r KLEEN-RITE CORPORATION & H. GREENSPAN
  
• 92-SCA-10 AMSEA & AMOS
  
• 92-SCA-12 James Bishop d/b/a Safeway Moving
  
• 92-SCA-13 ALVIN G. BAILEY
  
• 92-SCA-14 NATIONAL CENTER FOR TOXIC'L RESEARCH
  
• 92-SCA-15 LLOYD T. DANIELSEN, et al.
  
• 92-SCA-18 NORTHERN VIRGINIA SERVICE CORPORATION
  
• 92-SCA-18r NORTHERN VIRGINIA SERVICE CORPORATION
  
• 92-SCA-19 MELDICK SERVICES, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-20 PORSHIA ALEXANDER OF AMERICA, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-21 GINO MORENA ENTERPRISES
  
• 92-SCA-22 INDUSTRIAL MAINTENANCE SERVICE, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-23 INTERNATIONAL UNION OF OPERATING ENGINEERS & LOCAL 387
  
• 92-SCA-24 MAINTENANCE PACE SETTERS, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-25 RAMS SPECIALIZED SECURITY SERVICE, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-26 EXECUTIVE SUITE SERVICES, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-26r Executive Suite Services, Inc.
  
• 92-SCA-27 RURAL/METRO CORPORATION
  
• 92-SCA-28 Mason & Hanger- Silas Mason Corp.
  
• 92-SCA-29 ISLAND MOVERS, INC.
  
• 92-SCA-30 RAYMOND R. SCHAFER
  
• 92-SCA-31 Chas. Saunders d/b/a American Shamrock
  • See also Saunders v. Bush , 15 F.3d 64 (5th Cir. 1994)(immunity of federal officials)

• 92-SCA-32 THOMPSON BROTHERS, INC. 92-SCA-33 Technical Support Services, Inc.
  
• 92-SCA-34 Canteen Food & Vending Service
  
• 92-SCA-35 Fast Freight, Inc., et al.
  
• 92-SCA-36 Unified Services, Inc. & Jerry Davis, Jr
  
• 93-SCA-1 Lewis Management and Service, Inc.
  
• 93-SCA-2 Nevada Test Site
  
• 93-SCA-3 Raymond G. Richardson, Jr., et al.
  
• 93-SCA-4 HLJ Management & Hyman L. Jarrett
  
• 93-SCA-4r HLJ Management & Hyman L. Jarrett
  
• 93-SCA-6 Apex Investigations & Security Co., Inc.
  
• 93-SCA-7 Lanter Courier Corp.
  
• 93-SCA-8 SEIU re FRINGE BENEFITS (II)
  
• 93-SCA-10 National Cancer Institute (II)
  
• 93-SCA-11 Ebon Research Systems
  
• 93-SCA-12d HUGHES TECHNICAL SERVICES Co.
  
• 94-SCA-1 Ober United Travel Agency, Inc. et al.
  
• 94-SCA-2 SERVAIR, INC.
  
• 94-SCA-3 J.M. BAILEY & B&W TRUCKING & P. WILSON
  
• 94-SCA-4 Miller Enterprises, Inc.
  
• 94-SCA-5 The Swanson Group, Inc.
  
• 94-SCA-6 Kord's Metro Services, Inc.
  
• 94-SCA-7 Premium Wage Rates, Clear AFB, Alaska
  
• 94-SCA-8 United Food & Commercial Workers, LU1105
  
• 94-SCA-9 J&J Merrick's Enterprises, Inc.
  
• 94-SCA-10 Wage Determination No. 90-1029 (Rev. 6) as Applied to Service Contracts in Jasper County, Missouri
  
• 94-SCA-11d I.B.E.W. Local No. 82
  
• 94-SCA-12r ITT FEDERAL SERVICES
  
• 94-SCA-13 METROPOLITAN DISTRICT COUNCIL OF PHILADELPHIA AND VICINITY
  
• 95-SCA-2 CHARLES SAUNDERS, d/b/a AMERICAN SHAMROCK BUILDING MAINTENANCE
  
• 00-CBV-37 U.S. Cold Storage and Local 107
  
• 84-CBV-2r HARRY A. STROH ASSOCIATES, INC., ETC.
  
• 84-CBV-2 HARRY A. STROH ASSOCIATES, INC., ETC.
  
• 85-CBV-1 UNITED STATES COLD STORAGE, ETC.
  
• 86-CBV-1 LTR CORPORATION, ETC.
  
• 87-CBV-2 HARRY A. STROH ASSOCIATES, INC., ETC.
  
• 87-CBV-3 NORTHERN VIRGINIA SERVICE CORP., ETC.
  
• 87-CBV-7 MELDICK SERVICES, INC., ETC.
  
• 87-CBV-8 HYDE'S SECURITY SERVICES, INC.
  
• 88-CBV-4r INSTITUTIONAL & ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
  
• 88-CBV-4 INSTITUTIONAL & ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
  
• 88-CBV-7 BIG BOY FACILITIES, INC., ETC.
  
• 89-CBV-1 UNITED HEALTHSERV, INC.
  
• 86-OM-1r MILITARY SEALIFT COMMAND
  
• 86-OM-1 MILITARY SEALIFT COMMAND
  
• 86-OM-2 SYSTEMS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES CORP.
  
• 86-OM-3 SWANSON CORPORATION
  
• 86-OM-4 RICHARD M. MC GLUMPHY
  
• 86-OM-5 CACI, INC.
  
• 86-OM-7 BETTY P. MUNN
  
• 87-OM-1 LEWIS AND MICHAEL, INC.
  
• 87-OM-2 BURNSIDE-OTT
  
• 87-OM-3 SYSTEMS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES (SEACOR)
  
• 87-OM-4 SYSTEMS ENGINEERING ASSOCIATES (SEACOR)
  
• 87-OM-5 DYNCORP (FORMERLY DYNALECTRON CORP.)
  
• 87-OM-5s DYNCORP (FORMERLY DYNALECTRON CORP.)
  
• 87-OM-6 U.S. DEPT. OF ENERGY, PITTSBURGH REACTOR
  
• 87-OM-9 NATIONAL CANCER INSTITUTE
  
• 88-OM-1 BDM MANAGEMENT SERVICES COMPANY
  
• 88-OM-2r MERCURY CONSOLIDATED, INC.
  
• 89-OM-1 ENGINEERED SYSTEMS, INC.
  
• 90-OM-1 NEEB-KEARNEY AND COMPANY, INC.
  
• 90-OM-2 DYNCORP -- CHOLLAS HEIGHTS, CA.
  
• 90-OM-3 DIRECTORATE OF CONTRACTING, FT. HUACHUCA
  
• 91-OM-1 AQUASIS SERVICES, INC.
  
• 91-OM-1r AQUASIS SERVICES, INC.
  
• 91-OM-2 LOGISTICS SUPPORT GROUP
  
• 91-OM-5 HARBERT INTERNATIONAL, INC.
  
• 84-SCC-2 TEKONSHA MERCHANDISING EARN, INC., ET AL
  
• 85-SCC-4 ABLE BUILDING MAINTENANCE & SERVICE CO.
  
• 85-SCC-5 Tru Grain Corporation & James Moore
  
• 85-SCC-27 H. & A. JANITORIAL, INC.
  
• 85-WD-1 Lear Siegler, Inc. Management Services
  
• 85-WD-2 AMERICAN PHOTOGRAPHIC INDUSTRIES, INC.
  
• 85-WD-3 Aquasis Services, Inc.
  
• 85-WD-10 Northwest Forest Workers Association
  
• 85-WD-12 TRI-STATES SERVICE CO.
  
• 85-WD-30 Canteen Food and Vending Service
  
• 86-WD-1 U.S. DEPT. OF ENERGY
  
• 86-WD-2r Contract Services, Inc.
  
• 86-WD-2 CONTRACT SERVICES CO., INC.
  
• 86-WD-5 BENDIX FIELD ENGINEERING CORP.
  
• 86-WD-6 DONALD CLARK ASSOCIATES, INC.
  
• 86-WD-7r ERA Helicopters, Inc., et al.
  
• 86-WD-8 U.S. DEPT. OF INTERIOR, ELM, ET AL.
  
• 86-WD-12r GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION, REG. 6
  
• 86-WD-12 GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION, REG. 6
  
• 86-WD-13 Lewis & Michael Security Storage
  
• 86-WD-14 RG&B CONTRACTORS, INC. AND DESCO, INC.
  
• 87-WD-1 CRESCENT AIRWAYS, INC.
  
• 87-WD-3 PROFESSIONAL HELICOPTER PILOTS ASSN.
  
• 87-WD-4 FEDERAL SAVINGS & LOAN INSURANCE
  
• 87-WD-5 ZAPATA GULF MARINE CORPORATION
  
• 88-WD-1r U.S. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
  
• 88-WD-1 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
  
• 88-WD-2 C.F.S. AIR CARGO, INC.
  
• 88-WD-3 SEAL FLEET, INC.
  
• 89-WD-1 DELTA ASSOCIATES, LTD.
  
• 89-WD-2 DYNCORP, SHEPPARD ENJJPT DIVISION
  
• 89-WD-3 SERV-AIR, INC.
  
• 89-WD-4 PROFESSIONAL HELICOPTER PILOTS ASSN.
  
• 90-WD-1 RICHARD L. ROUDEBUSH VA MEDICAL CENTER
  
• 90-WD-3 NAT'L CENTER FOR TOXICOLOGICAL RESEARCH
  
• 90-WD-4 BENDIX FIELD ENGINEERING CORPORATION
  
• 91-WD-2 POSH CLEANING SERVICES
  

• 95-10 SUMMITT INVESTIGATIVE SERVICE, INC. (ARB CASE NO. 96-111; ALJ No. 1994-SCA-31)
  Final Decision & Order (Nov. 15, 1996)
  Final Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration (Mar. 27, 1997)